| West Chester History 1830 to
1865
by Jim Jones |
The Industrial Revolution
The Industrial Revolution is usually said to have started in
England in the 18th century with the introduction of the steam
engine, and to have spread from there to other parts of the world
over the next century. It changed so many things that a full
description of its effects would fill an entire course (or more).
By substituting machinery for human and animal power, improving
transportation, and increasing the consumption of resources and
the production of goods, industrialization altered the way people
lived. Generally, it increased life expectancies (although the
benefits did not reach everyone) and the number of things that
people owned. It reorganized work so that instead of making
complete objects, factory workers repeated the same simple task
over and over. Industrialization divided the country into
urban and rural sectors, enabling farmers to make
more money by selling to the townspeople. Improvements in the
speed an economy of transportation enabled people to see more of
the world than ever before. Industrialization had its downside
as well: it made war more deadly, increased pollution, produced
new kinds of accidents, and stimulated population densities that
favored the spread of epidemic disease.
Canals and Railroads
In the United States, the arrival of a steam engine was
usually the signal that industrialization had arrived in an area,
but railroads were not the first efforts to improve the region's
economic infrastructure. In an effort to extend the region's
river system, the first attempts involved the construction of
canals. One problem with river navigation is that water levels
change, so the earliest canals were built along existing rivers
to make them navigable for longer periods. The two examples in
Chester County were the Brandywine Creek Canal (authorized in
1793, never built), and the Schuylkill River Canal (authorized in
1815, opened to Phoenixville in 1828).
Although no canal was ever built to
West Chester, a prominent local resident, Dr. William Darlington,
was appointed to the first Pennsylvania Canal Commission in 1825,
where he served for two years including one as its president.
Although Darlington had no particular expertise in canals, he was
the first person from Chester County to obtain a medical degree
from the University of Pennsylvania (in 1804). He demonstrated
his abilities as a physician by serving at the County Poorhouse,
with a military regiment and on a merchant ship that sailed from
Philadelphia to Calcutta. Afterwards, he settled in West Chester
and married, became a trustee of the West Chester Academy
(founded 1811), served as an officer during the War of 1812, was
elected to Congress three times and conducted an inspection of
the military academy at West Point in 1822. In other words, he
had a national reputation, so when the state decided to form a
commission to regulate canals, he was a logical choice. Later,
his experience from that commission made him the unanimous choice
to head the group that built the West Chester Railroad.
Although canals were a big improvement over unpaved wagon
roads, they were still limited. Water ran low in late summer
and froze up in the winter. Canal boats moved slowly, making
them useful for moving heavy commodities that did not spoil, like
lumber and coal, but useless for more fragile items like fresh
food. In most places, canals were supplanted by railroads which
operated at much higher speeds and all the year round.
William Everhart and early development
Although men like William Darlington were leaders of the
community, newcomers began to make a mark in the 1820s. The most
successful was William Everhart, a shopkeeper who was born in
West Vincent. During his early years, he operated stores in West
Vincent, Tredyffrin, West Whiteland and West Goshen before he
bought a store in Gay Street in 1824. By then, he was no longer
a complete outsider because he married Hannah Matlack, the
granddaughter of one of the Borough's first farmers, in 1814.
Everhart made his money by selling imported English goods --
ceramics in particular -- and he became something of a legend
after he survived a shipwreck off the Irish coast, lost $10,000
in the process, and then declined to accept any of the money
found in the wreckage because he could not swear that it was his.
By 1829, Everhart had recovered from his loss and had enough
money to finance his greatest gamble. At the time, West Chester
consisted of four squares surrounding the intersection of High
and Gay Streets, and bounded by Church, Walnut, Chestnut and
South (later Market) Streets. Beyond those four squares lay
farms.
On February 19, 1829, Everhart bought the 102-acre Wollerton
farm located west of High Street and south of Gay Street. [Read
a partial transcription of the Everhart
deed.] Everhart paid $16,000, or just over $155 per acre,
which was high by the standards of the day -- Worthington had
failed twice before to sell his farm by auction. Although there
were many doubters, Everhart divided the land into building lots
and on the first day he sold fifty lots for more than the
original purchase lot. Everhart sold another twenty lots in 1830
and continued to hold land auctions into the 1840s. He also
built more than a hundred brick homes on his lots, laid out
Miner, Barnard, Darlington and Wayne Streets (named after his
friends), extended South Street west and made it wide enough for
a farmers market (leading to the renaming of the street about
1833).
Everhart's success inspired others -- Thomas Ogden, a
cabinetmaker and Methodist church leader who developed the area
between Gay and Market Street along New Street (including the
stone houses that line the west side of the 000-block of N. New
Street; farmer William Newlin sold five lots between Gay and
Chestnut Streets in 1830; and farmer George Ashbridge sold lots
on the north side of Chestnut west of High Street in 1831. In
1835, four investors from Philadelphia parcelled out the Matlack
farm bounded by High Street, Gay Street, Phoenixville Pike, and
Goshen Road.
Meanwhile, Everhart rapidly became the wealthiest man in the
Borough, surpassing the Darlingtons, the Sharplesses and the
other founding families. He built a new store for himself at
what is now 101 W. Market Street, and the Mansion House Hotel on
the opposite corner. He also became involved with railroad
construction, served one term on Borough Council and supported
other local politicians.
The West Chester Railroad
Until 1832 the only route to Philadelphia was via wagon
roads, unlike Chester or Norristown, which had connections by
water. On December 10, 1831, local attorneys Isaac Darlington
and P. Frazer Smith called a meeting at the Turk's Head Hotel to
discuss West Chester's response to the "Main Line of Public
Works," a state-funded project to connect Philadelphia to
Pittsburgh using a combination of rivers, canals and rails. The
state's plan called for the Main Line through the Great Valley
several miles north of the Borough, and the group feared that the
town would die if it were bypassed.
West Chester's location on high ground between two rivers
made it uneconomical to build a canal to reach the Main Line (too
many locks; not enough water). The only alternative was to build
an improved road. The designers of the Main Line faced a similar
problem between the Delaware and Susquehanna Rivers, and they
decided to construct a road paved with parallel wooden rails
topped with iron, over which a horse could draw heavily loaded
wagons. The West Chester group decided to do the same thing and
applied for a state charter to create a "railroad" to connect to
the Main Line at a convenient location.
"Railroad fever" was already strong in the coal regions of
Pennsylvania at that time, and West Chester's business community
was enthused about speculation thanks to the success of William
Everhart's development of the Wollerton farm. When West Chester
Railroad stock went on sale on March 22, 1831, people fought for
places in the line and the issue was oversold in less than two
hours.
The tracks were completed in September 1832, but service to
Philadelphia had to wait until the Main Line was completed in
October 1833. The WCRR used horses to pull wagons over nine miles
of wooden rails topped with iron strips, where they joined the
Main Line at "Intersection" (later Malvern) for the rest of the
journey to Philadelphia. The trip took about three hours, a great
improvement over the full-day trip normally required by wagons on
dirt roads, and that meant farmers around West Chester could more
readily sell perishable goods in the city. It also freed up farm
land closer to Philadelphia for other uses, so in the long run,
innovations like the WCRR allowed Philadelphia to expand.
Second generation borough politics
All of this development brought new money and people into the
Borough, and the "old-timers" tried to resist. The battles were
fought in a number of arenas, and ultimately in elections for
Borough Council.
One of the first disputes arose from Everhart's plans for the
streets in his development. In 1829, the south side of Gay
Street west of Church Street was lined with a series of narrow
lots which stretched south to the edge of Wollerton's farm.
Perhaps out of spite or a desire to insure some land sales,
Everhart laid out the South Street extension twelve feet south of
their property lines. The property owners complained to Borough
Council which appeared poised to reject Everhart's street plan,
so Everhart compromised by adding the twelve feet to the north
side of South Street, and offering the center of the street to
the Borough for use as a farmers market. The Borough built
market stalls in the center of the street in 1832, and later
expanded them in 1837 and 1845. Everhart lost nothing, since the
people who went to the farmers market also patronized his store
on the northwest corner of Church and South Street, and those
from distant parts of the County stayed overnight in his hotel on
the southeast corner.
Another form of dispute took place as a result of the
construction of the West Chester Railroad, and once again,
Everhart was at the center of it. The railroad ended at the
corner of Matlack and Chestnut Streets in the northeast part of
town, and Everhart realized that it would increase the value of
his land if the railroad continued across town. The owners of
the West Chester Railroad were all old-timers who had no interest
in enriching Everhart even further, so they refused, citing the
terms of their state charter.
Note: The early directors of the West Chester
Railroad included Dr. William Darlington (described above), Ziba Pyle (chief
burgess 1825-30), Jonathan Valentine (assistant burgess 1833-35),
and William Williamson, Joseph Hemphill, Jonathan Jones, Elihu
Chauncey, P. Frazer Smith and Samuel C. Jefferis -- all members
of West Chester's old guard.
Everhart started out by lobbying the state legislature to
reduce the price of stock shares specified in the West Chester
Railroad charter. Darlington and his colleagues resisted by
claiming that it was "less wasteful" to sell fewer shares at a
higher price. Reducing the number of stockholders, however, made
it harder for the Everhart faction to gain control of the board.
Everhart's next effort was to obtain a charter for the "West
Chester Extended Railroad" to build a spur across town from the
terminus of the West Chester Railroad. The WCRR directors fought
back with a lawsuit, and then altered their line to make the
connection as inconvenient as possible. Everhart built it anyway
in 1836, but it closed after only a few years.
Everhart's first foray into politics took place in 1831 when
he got five of his allies elected to Borough Council. (They
voted to build the new farmers market on his land in W. Market
Street.) Everhart's allies continued to dominate Borough Council
and, as the dispute between the West Chester Railroad and the
"Extended Railroad" reached a head, Everhart ran for Council
himself. He won, and his colleagues immediately chose him to be
the Chief Burgess and gave their approval to his railroad. When
Everhart and two other men went onto West Chester Railroad
property to start surveying their line, their opponents had them
arrested for trespassing. The judge was Dr. Darlington's brother
and he found them guilty, but perhaps fearing an appeal, fined
them only six cents each plus six cents in court costs.
Everhart left Borough Council after only two years (1836-7),
but he also served a single term in the US Congress in 1853-4.
Otherwise, he remained content to run his various businesses --
mercantile and construction -- until his retirement in 1867. He
died a year later.
The 1837 Depression
By the end of 1836, the atmosphere in West Chester was
positively exuberant. With the town expanding and the railroad
revolutionizing relations with Philadelphia, investors and
entrepreneurs flocked to the town to produce silk, open stores,
create transportation lines, and expand existing operations. The
National Bank of Chester County, which opened in 1814, completed
a neo-classical marble building on N. High Street using a design
by Thomas U. Walter. The Borough opened its first taxpayer-
funded public school that same year. The Chester County Cabinet
of Natural Science moved into a building on S. Church Street.
Expectations were high.
That all changed in 1837 when America suffered its first
economic depression. The Panic of 1837 grew out of the demise of
the Second National Bank that led to inflation, speculation in
land and imported goods, and ultimately, a huge foreign debt.
When foreign banks foreclosed, American state banks had to close.
The loss of savings and shortage of credit triggered an economic
depression that lasted from 1837 to 1843.
Locally, the Panic meant that there was no money for day-to-
day transactions, since banks no longer accepted paper money and
there were not enough coins in circulation. Everyone, from
craftsmen and merchants to the new Borough businesses suffered
from the loss of business. For instance, the "West Chester
Transportation Line," which operated wagons on the West Chester
Railroad, was forced to sell its rolling stock and look for
someone to lease its warehouse. The Bank of Chester County
closed its doors and lost half of its capital. The West Chester
Railroad stopped paying dividends to its stockholders, and had
to mortgage its property in order to stay open.
To replace the lost currency, the Borough borrowed $36,000
and issued small denomination banknotes which were were backed by
its ability to tax. That eased things locally, and other efforts
eased the crisis nationally, so that by 1839 the Panic appeared
to be over. Then a bad harvest in England triggered a second
crisis in 1839 which lasted until 1842. Confidence did not
return until early 1843.
The West Chester & Philadelphia Railroad
By the time that the Depression ended, the West Chester
Railroad was in bad shape. It had sold all of its rolling stock,
mortgaged real estate, and ceased paying dividends. Even worse,
it had powerful enemies on the Pennsylvania Canal Commission who
wanted to force them out of business because the WCRR's horse-
drawn wagons interfered with the use of steam locomotives on the
Main Line railroad. When the dispute reached the legislature,
farm interests backed the West Chester company while urban
interests backed the state company. Unable to prohibit the West
Chester Railroad from using horses, the Canal Commission fought
back by charging them high rates for the use of their track
between Malvern and Philadelphia.
West Chester businessmen, particularly men associated with
William Everhart, protested the Canal Commission's action. They
found allies in Philadelphia and Delaware County who were willing
to invest in a competing railroad. After a failed attempt in
1848, they received a charter for the West Chester & Philadelphia
Railroad in 1850. The problem was twofold -- by 1850 railroad
construction required much more money that in 1831, especially
since this line -- three times as long as the first one -- needed
several expensive bridges to cross tributaries of the Delaware
River. In addition, the owners of the WCRR waged a successful
campaign to undermine investor confidence in the new company, and
for the next eight years, the company struggled to raise money.
That led to lawsuits between stockholders, a boardroom coup,
bankruptcy and court-ordered receivership, but on November 11,
1858, the first train reached West Chester on the new line. The
final cost was more than $1.2 million dollars.
While the second railroad was under construction, the first
railroad revived, and in the process contributed another
innovation to the Borough. A new board of directors hired Samuel
Painter as the railroad's superintendent in 1843. During his
lifetime, he stared several businesses, and in 1850 he founded
the West Chester Telegraph Company to connect West Chester to the
line that ran along the Main Line. In addition to providing a
connection to a growing national telegraph network, Painter hired
Emma Hunter as the Borough's first operator. She is usually
referred to as the first woman telegraph operator in the US, if
not the world, and she must have exchanged messages with the
young Andrew Carnegie when he was a telegraph operator in
Pittsburgh.
The Civil War
With two competing railroads, West Chester was poised for
another period of economic progress. But before that got
underway, national events interfered once again. The Civil War
began in early 1860.
Locally, the Civil had few direct effects since West Chester
was far from the battlelines. But the indirect effects were
many, especially in a town dominated by Quakers who opposed war
as a matter of principle. One was a division that developed
within the Society of Friends in 1827 over how to respond to
slavery. The "Hicksite Friends" (named after Elias Hicks) were
the majority in Chester County -- they advocated a more
aggressive stance against slavery. By 1828, the West Chester
Friends had divided into two camps, each with their own meeting
house an later on, their own burial grounds. [ Note: The
Hicksites met on N. High Street and buried their dead on W.
Rosedale Avenue. The "Orthodox Friends" met on W. Chestnut
Street and buried their dead north of town.]
Another indirect effect was felt by West Chester's private
academies, many of which served the children of the South's
landed gentry. Also, before and during the war, the Underground
Railroad passed through Chester County, although not directly
through the Borough, which was too dangerous for fugitives who
would stand out in a town with constables and courts.
The war's direct effects included bitter local controversy
and the departure of roughly one-fifth of the town's able-bodied
male population to serve in Pennsylvania regiments. The debate
about the war started two weeks after Fort Sumter surrendered on
April 13, 1861, when the Chester County Times accused the
Borough's Democrats of treason and the Jeffersonian
printed their rebuttal that Lincoln and the radical abolitionists
had pushed the South into war.
Several military units were formed in the Borough, which sent
more than 300 men to the Union Army. The most famous was the
97th Regiment commanded by Henry Guss, the owner of the Greentree
Tavern. The Borough also turned over ten acres of the Chester
County Agricultural Fairgrounds, on what is now the site of West
Chester University residence halls. Military units formed at
what became known as "Camp Wayne" and trained there before
heading off to the war.
Although construction and agriculture suffered from the loss
of labor to the army, merchants probably benefitted from the
influx of military units. The greatest beneficiary of the Civil
War in West Chester was Uriah Painter, the son of Samuel Painter
(who started the telegraph company), who went to war as a
correspondent for the Philadelphia Inquirer. He had the
dubious good fortune to witness the Union defeat at the First
Battle of Bull Run, and the presence of mind to hop a freight
train to Baltimore before telegraphing his story to Philadelphia.
Because the government shut down all communications out of
Washington DC, the nearest town, in an effort to prevent the news
from demoralizing the North, Painter's newspaper was the first
one to print the story. After overcoming charges of treason for
reporting such horrible news, Painter acquired a reputation that
enabled him to become a powerful figure in Washington DC during
the second part of the 19th century. He will appear again later
in this course.
There are also some references to problems between the
soldiers and the local community, but most people preferred to
forget about that, as this quotation from the 1881 History of
Chester County by J. S. Futhey and Gilbert Cope suggests:
As the news of the battle and capture of the fort
by the rebels was flashed along the wires, excitement
unparalleled in the history of the county pervaded every
township, borough, village, hamlet, and fireside. Party
distinctions were forgotten, and a united people thought only of
the public peril and of means to defend the government. In
Chester County the feeling was intense, and all were animated
with a common purpose to maintain the Union at all hazards.
By the end of the Civil War, West Chester had lost its
connections with the South, but it had acquired a new generation
of war heroes, made money supplying the Union effort, and
developed rail and telegraph connections with the world. These
things would shape the Borough's history all of the way to
World War I.
Map Exercise
Compare the maps of West Chester in 1847 and 1873 (handed out
during class). What changes do you notice? What do you think
caused them?
Copyright 2007 by Jim Jones