West Chester news header
Get info on ... Latest News Local Government Local History WC Jim Links

The Future of the Wyeth Property
[Posted May 13, 2007]
Now that the Justice Center is nearing completion and development of the Paxson property at the west end of Dean Street is underway, West Chester residents and officials are considering the future of an even larger project -- the redevelopment of 32 acres between S. Adams, Bolmar and E. Nields Streets that used to house the Wyeth-Auerst factory. Last Thursday (May 10), about twenty people who attended the monthly meeting of the Southwest Association of Neighbors (SWAN) heard Business Improvement District director Malcolm Johnstone describe two possibilities for the site.  The Wyeth property in West Chester has been cleared
and leveled
The newly cleared Wyeth property, viewed from E. Nields Street
Since the Wyeth factory closed in 2004, company and Borough officials have been seeking someone to take over the property along with Wyeth's obligation to subsidize the operation of the Goose Creek Sewage Treatment Plant. In the past year, a demolition company has removed all buildings and parking lots from the site, and leveled the resulting turf. The result is an enormous open space more typical of a rural township than the Borough, which has been almost completely "built-out" for decades.

According to Johnstone, a company called Pennsylvania Real Estate Investment Trust (PREIT) has expressed interest in building a mixture of commercial, office and residential space on the site -- perhaps 100,000 square feet of office space, the same amount of commercial space, and "hundreds of condominiums," all served by as many as three parking garages. According to recent news reports, PREIT owns shopping malls in fourteen states including the Exton Square Mall, Main Street at Exton, and the Echelon Mall in ou region, and has proposed a new "town-center" development for New Garden Township. [Daily Local News 2/7/2004, 5/16/2005, 4/7/2007 & Philadelphia Inquirer 7/13/2005] Johnstone said that PREIT could extend the Wyeth project across Bolmar Street into West Goshen if it can acquire land, and that it have to redesign roads in the area to handle the increased traffic.

The second proposal for the site has been offered by West Chester mayor Dick Yoder on behalf of another group that is interested in constructing a minor league baseball stadium. The stadium would occupy about eight of the 32 acres and serve a "High A" team (below AA and AAA) for one of the major league teams. Johnstone explained that a baseball stadium could pay for itself, but would be unlikely to generate additional revenue for the Borough directly through income, business or property taxes. Instead, the benefit to the Borough would come from the stadium's role as an additional (WCJIM: hopefully non-alcoholic) way to attract people to West Chester.

According to Johnstone, the two proposals are not mutually exclusive: i.e. a stadium on part of the site would still allow the rest of the site to be developed for other uses like those proposed by PREIT. He also said that the purpose of his presentation was not to promote either proposal, but instead to get Borough residents to start thinking about the future of the site.

Although it was not discussed at the meeting, there is one other entity with an interest in using part of the property -- the Borough itself. Last March, Council approved a feasibility study to examine the needs of the Public Works Department for, among other things, more space. With 32 acres of open space on the verge of redevelopment, it is a sure bet that Public Works Director Bob Wilpizeski has given some thought to what his department could do with a piece of that property.


Walking Tours Set To Go
[Posted May 23, 2007]
Every year, West Chester hosts its share of walking tours, and 2007 will be no different. A dozen local history experts have created tours for the 13th Annual "Summer Town Tours and Village Walks," which kicks off in West Chester on Thursday, June 7 at 6pm from the Holy Trinity Episcopal Church at High & Union Streets. This year's tour is sponsored by the County Department of Parks and Recreation, the Borough Historical and Architectural Review Board, and the Historic South Walnut Neighborhood Association.

Every year, West Chester hosts its share of walking tours, and 2007 will be no different. A dozen local history experts have created tours for the 13th Annual "Summer Town Tours and Village Walks," which kicks off in West Chester on Thursday, June 7 at 6pm from the Holy Trinity Episcopal Church at High & Union Streets. This year's tour is sponsored by the County Department of Parks and Recreation, the Borough Historical and Architectural Review Board, and the Historic South Walnut Neighborhood Association.

 Part of the Mercer development in the 100-block of S.
Walnut Street
Part of the "Mercer development" on South Walnut Street

The tours will cover the "South High Street Corridor" which extends for about two blocks to either side of High Street south of Market. It includes a major road with colonial-era roots, the Borough's first major housing development (the 1830 Everhart tract), the railroad corridor, and some of West Chester's most elegant residential architecture. The dozen guides includes current HARB, Zoning Hearing Board and Recreation Commission members, plus several former members. They include land planners, professors, and professional archivists, plus a number of enthusiastic and highly skilled "amateurs."

Each has created a tour based on his or her particular interest, so no two tours are exactly the same. For instance, Chuck Ullman and Tom Walsh offer the whimsically-titled "Ladies of the Everhart Tract" and "From Penn's Wood to Hollywood!" Ray Ott's title, "Transitions: The Development of the Mercer and Bolmar Tracts in Southeastern West Chester," betrays his credentials as a professional land planner. Bill McLaughlin and Nathaniel Smith each offer tours with architectural themes -- S. High Street and S. Walnut Street, respectively -- while Jon Long, a former archivist who currently works for State Rep. Barbara McIlvaine Smith, will take a look at the "Churches of the Everhart Tract." Others tours will focus on neighborhood anecdotes and personalities including Jim Jones's look at working class life east of High Street, David Wickard "Back Streets & Alleyways" west of High Street, and Jane Dorchester's "Tall Tales & Tidbits!"  West Chester Town Tour guides meet to discuss their
routes
The "Town Tour" guides plan their routes

One title looks especially interesting to local historians: Mary Sprout's "Mr. Rodebaugh's West Chester." Sprout was a close friend and collaborator of Paul Rodebaugh, West Chester's most celebrated local historian. Rodebaugh lived most of sixty one years in a house on Sharpless Street across from the University, and became known as a writer, speaker and collector of local historic artifacts -- mostly books, but also plenty of other objects. Sprout accompanied him on walking tours and road trips, and aided him with his research thanks to her position in the Chester County Archives. Her tour will offer a unique insight into the man who taught Chester County much of its history.

To hear more about West Chester's "Town Tour and Village Walk," listen to WCJIM's interview with Jane Dorchester on "Talk About West Chester" this Thursday, May 24, between 8-10am.


Biking in the Borough
[Posted June 1, 2007]
With the Third Annual Iron Hill Twilight Criterium bicycle race scheduled to take place on Saturday, July 7, coupled with some excellent weather these last few weeks, interest in Borough bicycling has increased. An avid cyclist himself, WCJIM decided to take a look at bicycling in West Chester.

Bicycling in an urban environment is quite different from touring the countryside. Obviously, there are more people and other vehicles to contend with, but there are also physical obstacles that require some additional skills. For instance, the paved walkways of West Chester University provide an excellent surface for cycling (except when classes are changing), but they also feature curbs and stairways. Strong legs may permit a rider to go around stairways, but riding over curbs is a sure way to break wheel spokes. The alternative is a maneuver called "dismount/remount" in which the cyclist hops off of the bike, grabs it with one hand, carries it over the obstacle and then hops back on again. With only a little practice, a dismount/remount can be accomplished with the loss of only a few seconds -- less time than it takes to find a curb cut.

 unidentified bicyclist
A typical Borough cyclist
 riders in the 2006 Criterium Bike Race in West Chester
PA
Some atypical Borough cyclists from the 2006 Criterium Race
The other major concern with urban biking is the proximity to other traffic. Oddly enough, bicycling in the Borough is fairly safe according to data supplied by the West Chester Police Department. Since the beginning of 2007, they have recorded only three accidents involving bicycles, compared to more than 150 involving motor vehicles, and none of the bicycle accidents were fatal. There are a number of reasons. First, the number of bicyclists is relatively small. In addition, they are relatively savvy, wearing helmets and high-visibility clothing, and using lights. Third, with West Chester's short blocks and high rate of congestion, neither bicycles nor motor vehicles reach speeds that can cause fatalities. Of course, that's not a all true on Market or Gay Street east of Adams, on High Street north of Marshall or on Downingtown Pike north of Strasburg Road, but everywhere else in the Borough traffic moves slowly enough to give riders a chance to get out of the way.

A far greater danger, according to the police, is that of bicycle theft. Since the beginning of 2007, the Borough has received reports of 21 stolen bicycles, and each year both the Borough and University police departments hold sales to dispose of recovered bikes whose owners could not be identified. Some bikes are never recovered, although a group of volunteers retrieved several from Goose Creek at E. Nields Street during the Earth Day community clean-up.

Local agencies have made efforts to promote bicycle riding by installing secure racks at a number of locations. West Chester University has the largest selection but both the Court House and Borough Hall are also equipped. Various streetscape projects introduced racks along Gay Street, and there is a good assortment of sturdy street lamps and poles to which a bike can be secured. Here's a request, however: Do not lock your bike to any of the Borough's street trees -- choose a metal or wooden pole instead.

 bike rack
Bike rack on Gay Street

 View from the Struble Bike Trail
Along the Struble Trail

For riding at high speeds, you have to get out of the Borough (o else take your chances with the traffic on E. Market Street -- not recommended). The West Chester Cycle Club organizes weekly group bike rides and offers a variety of trip plans on their web site. For people who prefer to get out of traffic, there are dedicated bicycle trails in Downingtown, Uwchlan and Valley Forge.

For a short ride, head to Kerdon Park on the east side of Downingtown where the four-mile Struble Bike Trail follows the old East Brandywine & Waynesburg Railroad right-of=way north to Dorlan Road at the far end of Dowlin Forge Park. From there, if your legs are up to it, you can climb the hill to Marsh Creek State Park, but if they're not, you can return to the south end of Dowling Forge Park and take a side trip along the Uwchlan Township Trail.

For a longer ride, head to Valley Forge, cross the Schuylkill River on US422 and take the first exit for Trooper Road. Instead of following the traffic to the right, turn left at the top of the ramp and follow the signs to the boat landing at Betzwood. The parking lot is only a few feet away from a railroad line that has been converted into a bicycle path that runs from northern Montgomery county to Philadelphia. Heading east towards Norristown provides an interesting mix of industrial and urban landscapes, while heading west takes you along the Schuylkill River to the Perkiomen Creek and some fairly spectacular southeastern Pennsylvania scenery.

How to hang on to your bike: If you can't store your bicycle inside, use a case-hardened steel lock (cable locks can be cut easily). It doesn't hurt to take the bike's front wheel with you when you park the bike. But before you do anything else, write down the make, model, color and serial number of your bicycle and store that information in a safe place along with something that proves you own the bicycle (the sales receipt is best), The police need that before they can return your bike, if its ever stolen and recovered.


Volunteer English Program Celebrates 20th Year
[Posted June 4, 2007]
Last Friday (June 1), Longwood Gardens hosted a breakfast to honor approximately 170 staff, volunteers and supporters of the Volunteer English Program in Chester County (VEP), which is celebrating its 20th anniversary this year. In addition to an excellent breakfast in an impressive room, they heard short speeches by graduates, board members and distinguished guests, and got to roam around the gardens for the rest of the morning.
The distinguished speakers were federal Judge Juan Sanchez and State Senator Andrew Dinniman, both members of the VEP's "Honorary Council" (although Dinniman was kept away at the last minute, so his chief of staff, Stephanie Beemer, delivered remarks on his behalf). Dinniman is well-known in West Chester and his support for the VEP spans the full twenty years. Sanchez started out as a lawyer for Legal Aid and the Public Defender's Office, then won election to the Common Pleas Court in 1999, and most recently was appointed to the US Circuit Court by President Bush in 2004. His own experience -- arriving on the USA mainland from Puerto Rico at age 12 speaking only Spanish -- taught him about the value of the service provided by the VEP.  guests at the Volunteer English Program 20th
anniversary breakfast
Some of the guests at the Volunteer
English Program 20th anniversary dinner
West Chester was very well represented along the guests. On addition to VEP President Bill Lalicker, who teaches in the WCU English Department and lives in the Borough, WCJIM spotted Common Pleas judicial candidate Jennifer Levy-Tatum, Public Works Director Bob Wilpizeski, former Planning Commission chair Nancy Klabunde, Zoning Hearing Boad member Dawn L'heureux, and former Borough Council candidate Michael Bacchini, among others.

They were all there to support a good cause. The VEP organizes volunteer tutors who assist recent immigrants with English lessons as well as with "acculturation" -- the process of becoming familiar with attitudes and behaviors in the United States. For example, some cultures treat direct eye contact as a threatening act, but in order to interview for a job in this country, eye contact is a plus. Information like that is difficult to come by, but VEP tutors and their students develop personal relationships that enable them to exchange information that goes beyond grammar and vocabulary.

According to VEP President Lalicker, program volunteers donated more than 11,000 hours of their time last year to over 200 students from forty different countries. One of those students, Alex Loboda, spoke to the crowd about his experience as an immigrant from the Ukraine where he worked as a endocrinologist at a hospital that treated, among other people who were injured by the Chernobyl disaster. He explained how, besides improving his English, his tutor helped him learn the behaviors he needed to interact successfully with patients and colleagues in an American hospital.

There were three messages from the event that are worth sharing on this web page. First, at a time when zealots in the immigration debate have tried to make the word "immigrant" inseparable from "illegal," it is important to remember that there are thousands of legal immigrants in the United States (24,000 in Chester County alone). Second, the Volunteer English Program needs more tutors. Third, even though the Program receives some funding from the PA Department of Education and the United Way, it relies heavily on private donations.

To learn more about the Volunteer English Program, visit their web site at volunteerenglish.org. To volunteer, call Linda Grosse at 610-918-8222 or send her an email or a fax at 610-918-8223. To send a donation, make out a check payable to "Volunteer English Program in Chester County" and send it to VEP at 790 E. Market Street, Suite 215, West Chester, PA 19382.


A Look at District Courts
[Posted June 8, 2007]
Pennsylvania's magisterial district courts are the gateway to a state justice system that stretches upwards through county Courts of Common Pleas, Commonwealth Court and the state Supreme Court. As such, district courts handle an extraordinary number and variety of cases. Nowhere is that more true than in West Chester, whose two district courts are the busiest in the entire county. This article examines data from the Pennsylvania Court Administration web site and adds some observations from West Chester Unplugged, an independent web site that reports on the Borough's district courts and activity by police and other first responders.

West Chester is home to two district courts: #15-1-01 on the west side and #15-1-04 on the east (Chester County is #15 in the state; the Borough is in district #1, and our courts are #1 and #4, respectively). Until 2004, there was only a single court, but the workload in that court was so great that the state authorized its division into two separate districts. Even so, both remain tops in the County in terms of numbers of cases, even though they cover the smallest area of any district court in the country. Both are under a square mile, compared to Kennett Square (#15-3-04), which covers roughly sixty square miles, or West Goshen (#15-2-03), which covers more than twenty-five square miles.

 West Chester's district justices
West Chester's district justices
In 2006, the first year for which full data is available, the two Borough courts ranked one and two in the County for total cases filed, with the West side edging out the East by 16,413 to 15,568. Both were far ahead of the next three courts: Downingtown, with 11,051; Phoenixville with 8,589; and East Brandywine/Caln, with 8,553. To put those numbers into perspective, the average case load throughout the entire county was 7,634 in 2006. Surprisingly Coatesville, which is often considered to have a high crime rate, falls below West Chester. It is actually divided between two courts which also cover neighboring townships and which rank 11 and 13 in total cases. If they were combined, they would rank third with 11,374, but they would also cover and area seven times larger than West Chester.

Court Number of cases in 2006 Jurisdiction
#15-1-01 16,413 west side of West Chester
#15-1-04 15,568 east side of West Chester
#15-2-06 11,051 Downingtown, East Caln, West & East Brandywine, Birmingham
#15-2-01 8,589 Phoenixville, West Vincent, Schuylkill, Charlestown
#15-4-02 8,553 East Brandywine, Caln
#15-1-03
& #15-1-05
11,374 Coatesville, South Coatesville, Valley
All 19 courts 145,101 All of Chester County

Most of the difference in cases heard between the two West Chester courts came from traffic offenses. The West side led the county with 14,302, while the East side was second with 12,615. The East side led the County in other categories -- non-traffic and miscellaneous filings -- and came in fifth for criminal filings behind Downingtown's court #15-2-06. The Borough's West side court came in fourth, seventh and tenth in those categories.

Measuring performance : In an ideal world, the best way to measure the performance of a district court would be to examine its "recidivism rate" -- the percentage of people found guilty who commit another offense -- and a low recidivism rate would be evidence of success. Unfortunately there is no good way to cross-reference convictions from our district courts with those of other counties and states. Another useful measure would be overall crime rate within a court's jurisdiction, but since so many other factors affect that, a change cannot be attributed to the district court alone.

The Borough does track the amount of revenue collected by district courts to cover fines and court costs. State law specifically prohibits municipalities from relying on fines to meet their budget needs, but fines are an important source of revenue, they force defendants to make some sort of restitution to the community, and many people believe they discourage offenders from committing further criminal acts (despite the evidence, available to anyone who drives on US Route 202, that speeding tickets do not reduce speeding). On the other hand, there are ways for district justices to increase court revenue without affecting the amount of crime, so revenue is at best an imperfect measure of performance.

Statistics from the Borough Treasurer's office for 2006 show that the Borough's two district courts perform about the same when it comes to generating revenue. The majority comes from parking and traffic offenses, and with a slight advantage in those types of cases, the West side court generated just under $401,000 with 15,675 cases in 2006, compared to slightly less than $374,000 for 14,691 cases in the East side court. That works out to an average of $25.58 per case on the West side and $25.44 on the East side. (These totals exclude cases that generated no revenue for the Borough.)

Why are Borough courts so busy? One is the number of liquor licenses in town -- 65% of the non-criminal cases on the East side involved alcohol. Another is the Borough's relatively young population -- nearly 40 percent is between 18 and 24, according to the 2000 US Census -- which is associated with a high rate of non-violent crime. A third factor is the large number of people who visit the Borough by automobile, coupled with population density that creates crowded streets and leaves parking in short supply. Population density probably provides a fourth explanation -- even though their jurisdiction are small, they contain a lot of people and are augmented by the West Chester University population for nine months of each year.

To learn more about what goes on in the Borough's district courts, try to visit the West side court (720 E. Market St.) on Tuesday morning or the East side court (530 E. Union St.) on Friday morning, which each holds its respective "Criminal Day" (they are staggered so that police officers can appear at either court). There is also a website for the East side court at www.judgeknapp.com.


Today's the Day that Market Street Closes
[Posted June 11, 2007]
As of this morning, Market Street is closed between New and Darlington Streets, most likely for the rest of the summer, while contractors reconstruct the road between the Justice Center and the parking garage. The closure is scheduled to last until September 3, but will end as soon as the work is finished. In the meanwhile, drivers arriving from Downingtown are urged to use the 322 bypass, while local traffic will use Wollerton Street to get between Market and Darlington. To make access to W. Market Street easier, the direction of traffic on Darlington Street has been reversed from Gay to Market Street.  sign announcing the closing of Market Street


Eli Kahn's Skyscraper Proposal
[Posted June 15, 2007]
One side effect of changing building codes is last-minute applications to avoid the effects of change. The past year's discussion of height limits proved no different, and local developer Eli Kahn submitted an application on April 23, 2007 to build a 110-foot building a block west of the new Justice Center. Although only he knows if he will ever build such a structure, Borough officials are obliged to take it seriously. In addition, even though the Borough has expressed its collective will that buildings should not go higher than 90 feet, Kahn's right to build higher is protected by state law.  Approximate bulk of the proposed building
Approximate size of the proposed building (in red)
viewed from Justice Center Parking Garage
Filing under the name of "Free Range Associates" (a not-too- subtle reference to the anti-regulation cattle ranchers of the 19th century who opposed efforts to fence off the American West), Kahn proposes to build an eight-story building with two floors of parking at ground level and six floors of office space on top. The building will replace the former IGA grocery store at 313 West Market Street, and also cover a portion of the parking lot immediately to the west. The proposal also relies on another section of the same parking lot to meet the parking requirement, but will not place any new structure on that part of the lot. The two sections of parking lot are separated by a third section which is owned by Stan & Elsa Zukin, but it plays no role in the proposed development.
The application shows a building that fronts on Market Street and extends roughly 154 feet north to Harmony Alley, with the minimum setbacks needed to provide a sidewalk along Market Street and a bit of landscaping along Harmony Alley. The eastern end of the building will be set back five feet from Potter Alley (which runs parallel to and west of New Street), and the building will extend westward for 180 feet. The entrance to the lower parking level will be on Harmony Alley, while the entrance to the upper level will be from Potter Alley. The two parking levels will provide a total of 121 parking spaces while the surface lot farther west will provide 32 more -- enough to serve 114,000 square feet of office space on six floors, according to the application.  The former IGA grocery store on W. Market St.
The former IGA grocery store on W. Market St.
The lowest two floors of office space will cover the entire 180' x 154' footprint, but in order to meet the requirements for an over-sized building, the top four floors will be set back about sixteen feet on the Market Street and Harmony Alley sides. The result will be a profile that, when viewed from the Potter Alley side, will look like a fat, upside-down letter T. When viewed from the Market Street side -- say from the parking lot of Mitch's Gym -- it will resemble a large rectangle covered with about forty percent glass, thirty percent brick and the rest concrete. The design was prepared by the Kennett Square firm of Bernardon, Haber & Holloway, the architects for the Justice Center and Kahn's other tall building at 121 North Walnut Street. One critic described the look as "big box with accents," and certainly compared to the Justice Center, the building shown in the application is fairly plain.

One other feature of the plan is unusual -- the complete absence of any commercial or other "pedestrian-friendly" space on the ground floor. Instead, there is a small lobby in the southeast corner nearest Market Street and Potter Alley that provides access to the office space which begins on the second floor, but otherwise there will be only parking spaces which will be screened from the view of passersby. Since the "conditional use standards" for the height overlay district prohibit using the "first floor/ground floor" exclusively for parking and/or offices, and instead require "a continuation and continuity of shop fronts and stores," this aspect of the plan will probably require some marketing when Council hears the application. [See Code of the Borough of West Chester, Chapter 112-33.1(B)(2) for details.]

The Proposed Building -- From Top to Bottom
Floor Use Height* Note
8 Offices 14'  
7 Offices 14'  
6 Offices 14'  
5 Offices 14' The approx. 16' setbacks on the Market Street and Harmony Alley sides begin on this floor.
4 Offices 14'  
3 Offices 14'  
2 Parking 14' Automobile entrance from Potter Alley. Also includes a pedestrian entrance and lobby with elevators to upper floors at the corner of Market Street and Potter Alley. **
1 Parking 11' Automobile entrance from Harmony Alley. This floor begins 4' below the ground level at Harmony Alley and 7' below grade at Market Street.
* Total height = 109'
** A stair tower in the middle of the west wall connects all floors.
That will take place next Monday, June 18, at 6:30pm at Borough Hall, when Council holds the conditional use hearing on Kahn's application. Expect some fireworks, because neighbors from that part of town have already expressed their opposition to the project in private, and the very notion of a 110-foot building, coming after months of public debate on ways to lower the height limit, makes this application appear to be an example of a developer yielding to greed in opposition to the public interest.

There is another way to look at it, however, and it is supported by state law. That's the view that an earlier Borough Council agreed that buildings up to 180 feet were acceptable, so until the new height ordinance is enacted, that standard remains in effect. By submitting his application before Council could complete the height revision, Kahn preserved the opportunity to build according to the earlier standard. Council can hold him to the conditions prescribed by that standard, but it cannot deny the project based on a standard that is not yet law. The only forces that can persuade Kahn to comply with the new, lower standard are real estate economics, public opinion, and his own conscience.


Results of the Hearing on Kahn's Skyscraper
[Posted June 18, 2007]
In a hearing that lasted about two and a half hours this evening (Monday, June 18), Borough Council heard a presentation by developer Eli Kahn and his lawyer for a 110-foot tall office building on West Market Street. As the Borough's solicitor Michael Gill explained, the purpose was to see if the developer met the conditions for a use (a tall building) that was permitted by the Borough Zoning Code.
Every member of Council raised questions, and a number of residents spoke as well. There was little sympathy for Kahn from the neighbors of the site, who heard Kahn defend his proposal as an effort to preserve the value of land that he bought for development four years ago. After meeting briefly in a private "executive session" to discuss their legal options, Council voted 6-1 (Christy opposed) to continue the public hearing on Monday, July 23 at 6:30pm, so they could have more time to examine a traffic study and other documents that arrived at the beginning of the meeting.  Architect's rendering of Eli Kahn's proposed building,
viewed from near the corner of W. Market St. and Potter Alley
Architect's rendering of the proposed building, viewed from the southeast


 

Copyright 2007 by Jim Jones